I awoke this morning to a textual content from a detailed good friend questioning how lengthy it could take me to jot down about the truth that as of this writing, we nonetheless would not have outcomes from the Iowa caucuses final night time resulting from issues with its untried voting app. I assume I’m firmly established on the “get off my garden” beat.
The little-known corollary to the time-honored maxim “if it ain’t broke, don’t repair it” is “if it’s broke, don’t change it with one thing worse.” The checklist of potential issues with utilizing cellular know-how for one thing as vital as voting is lengthy. Rule One is perhaps “don’t rent an organization named ‘Shadow, Inc.’ to construct your app.” A fellow Hoya, Matt Blaze, a professor of pc science and regulation at Georgetown, stated that “any sort of app or program that depends on utilizing a cellphone community to ship outcomes is susceptible to issues each on the app and on the telephones getting used to run it . . . and that “[t]he consensus . . . is unequivocal . . .[i]nternet and cellular voting shouldn’t be used at the moment in civil elections.”
Any distant entry utility will add complexity to a activity as a result of want for identification, authentication, authorization, and safety, of each the machine and the individual utilizing it, versus an easier system based mostly on paper or a single machine for every location the place any caucus participant may authenticate herself in individual. A number of know-how platforms merely enhance complexity and probability of error. And, as I realized within the cellular fee world, in case you are counting on good cell service or wifi availability in your app to do its work, you’re gonna have some sad end-users.
Add to those inherent issues that the app was reportedly solely put collectively over the past two months and was inadequately examined. (Apparently, it was the back-up plan; the unique plan was to make use of the telephone to name in votes. “Hello, do you might have Pete Buttigieg in a can?”)
Simply because you may doesn’t imply you need to. I’ve been bringing a yellow authorized pad and ballpoint (or “ink pen” down right here) to conferences for years. Purchasers and colleagues commonly smile indulgently, as if I had simply set a butter churn down on the desk. My inventory response is perhaps acceptable for the beleaguered people in Iowa and I supply it right here without cost: Paper not often goes down, by no means must be recharged, doesn’t want an adapter and, better of all: I understand how it really works.
Learn this text on the Hey Data Data blog.
Copyright © 2020 Womble Bond Dickinson (US) LLP All Rights Reserved.